Judge: JCP Interfered with Macy's-MSLO Agreement

JCPenney_2014_ClassicNEW YORK-The New York State Supreme Court Justice hearing the lawsuit by Macy's against J.C. Penney and Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia (MSLO) has ruled that J.C. Penney "tortiously interfered" with the agreement between Macy's and MSLO.

In the 63-page ruling, Justice Oing said Macy's had proven that it had a valid contract with MSLO for its Martha Stewart line of home goods, that J.C. Penney knew of the this contract even while negotiating with MSLO on its own deal for a Martha Stewart line of home goods.

Oing's ruling left the issue of damages somewhat up in the air, saying "the issues of damages and attorney's fees are respectfully referred to a judicial hearing officer or special referee." The justice noted that Macy's and its chairman and CEO, Terry Lundgren, had been "vindicated." The justice said the J.C. Penney and Martha Stewart agreement "placed JCP on the verge of financial collapse. I find that these significant facts are a sufficient deterrent to JCP and other companies from acting in a similar way in the future."

In a statement, Macy's said, "We are delighted, but certainly not surprised, that the court has found tortious interference by JCP. It is a great shame that Macy's had to expend time, money, and the diversion of its resources in order to protect its rights. We look forward to the damages phase of the case."

J.C. Penney had not responded to an HFN request for comment by press time.

The J.C. Penney-Stewart collaboration was a crucial part of former J.C. Penney CEO Ron Johnson's strategy to reformat the department-store retailer into a group of branded, boutique-style shops. Macy's sued MSLO over the J.C. Penney deal at about the same time it renewed its agreement with the company, and sued J.C. Penney in August 2012. Macy's and MSLO settled their dispute in January of this year.

HFN Staff | News & Commentary

HFN provides detailed information on the key home classifications: Housewares, Tabletop, Floor Covering & Rugs, Furniture, Home Textiles, Lighting, Home Decor, Mattresses & Bedding, Gifts, Major Appliances and Consumer Electronics as well as Business, Finance and Retail.

Videos

Subscribe to
HFN Omnichannel
Receive the news you need to know about the trends in the industry delivered right to your inbox.

Current Issue

  • HFN May digital issue

    HFN's DIGITAL EDITION

    May 2017


    COVER STORY: HFN Turns 90

    We commemorate HFN's 90th anniversary by paying tribute to the iconic retailer and supplier brands--and the people--that have helped the industry flourish, then and now.


    ALSO IN THIS ISSUE:

    • Up & Coming Leaders - The home industry is in capable and visionary hands as this year’s 40 Under 40 list attests. Today’s young leaders span all disciplines and varied levels of operation.
    • Omnichannel Retailing - In the Mobile App World, Time is Money